Be able to join PVP in 1.8.

[SlipperyEJ]

woops woops can we delete that post woops lmao accidently just quoted myself and posted it wtf :O

 

[Lilleh__]

In 1.9, it's about timing hits. If you miss a hit and the other person hits you, the chances are different, or if you hit to early you do less damage. This opens up the chances of winning a battle for someone with less armor or a worse sword, because it's now about timing your hits, as where with 1.8 every hit did damage no matter the time in between, so someone with better armor wouldn't need to do as much to kill someone with worse gear.

Still possible to miss hits in 1.8.

 

[A pigeon]

@CommunistCactusfanboy

 

[Deeds]

So you think 1.8 is just straight on battle where both opponents press w and hit eachother and its all about who clicks faster?

Yes. It is indeed.
Unlike 1.9, I don’t need to rely on whether I can rod people or not. Nor do I have to realy on who has the better weapon or sword.

1.8: Armour + Sword = Win
1.9: Armour + Sword = IT DOESN’T MATTER
I have 3v1’ed people in full iron, while in full leather. Just gotta say I kicked their butts.
In 1.8 I did the same thing, except it was a 2v1. I got my butt kicked.

In 1.8 it’s mainly the armour/weapons. CPS also plays a factor, the faster the better.
In 1.9 it’s mainly about skill and timing of hits. CPS doesn’t matter one bit.

1.8 although you dont need timing as much, it still requires skill and even more than 1.9 in my opinion.

 

[Qin Shihuangdi]

Title says it all. Better hitboxes, hit detection, blockhitting, better animations and more. Not saying 1.8 pvp is better (Even though I think it is).

Better hit boxes = fake news. Git gud
Hit detection = 1.13 is 10x better
Blockhitting = Useless unless you can get above 20 CPS (and rheumatoid arthritis)
Better animations = Texture Pack

This is the problem. You guys refuse to let go of the 20-cps-required-glitch even if a server can perfectly replicate everything else. Just let the glitch go and know that everything else can be brought back lmao

 

[SlipperyEJ]

Yes. It is indeed.
Unlike 1.9, I don’t need to rely on whether I can rod people or not. Nor do I have to realy on who has the better weapon or sword.

1.8: Armour + Sword = Win
1.9: Armour + Sword = IT DOESN’T MATTER
I have 3v1’ed people in full iron, while in full leather. Just gotta say I kicked their butts.
In 1.8 I did the same thing, except it was a 2v1. I got my butt kicked.

In 1.8 it’s mainly the armour/weapons. CPS also plays a factor, the faster the better.
In 1.9 it’s mainly about skill and timing of hits. CPS doesn’t matter one bit.


View attachment 140067

Better hit boxes = fake news. Git gud
Hit detection = 1.13 is 10x better
Blockhitting = Useless unless you can get above 20 CPS (and rheumatoid arthritis)
Better animations = Texture Pack

This is the problem. You guys refuse to let go of the 20-cps-required-glitch even if a server can perfectly replicate everything else. Just let the glitch go and know that everything else can be brought back lmao

 

[OnePointEight.exe]

Better hit boxes = fake news. Git gud
Hit detection = 1.13 is 10x better
Blockhitting = Useless unless you can get above 20 CPS (and rheumatoid arthritis)
Better animations = Texture Pack

This is the problem. You guys refuse to let go of the 20-cps-required-glitch even if a server can perfectly replicate everything else. Just let the glitch go and know that everything else can be brought back lmao

What 20 cps glitch, I'll have you know that anything divisible by 2 does max dps in 1.8, clicking faster (WHILE HITTING ALL THESE CLICKS) only reduces the knock back you take, if this is what bug you are talking about then... I don't know what, it's not that large of an advantage. Better ANIMATIONS can not be fixed with a TEXTURE pack, grow a brain. Also jittering can not cause arthritis, arthritis is only caused by external sources such as jack hammers. I am not going to talk about hit reg because I know next to nothing about it, all I know is 1.7 > 1.8.

1.8: Armour + Sword = Win
1.9: Armour + Sword = IT DOESN’T MATTER
I have 3v1’ed people in full iron, while in full leather. Just gotta say I kicked their butts.
In 1.8 I did the same thing, except it was a 2v1. I got my butt kicked.

May I simply ask what enchants the armor had, perhaps prot 4 since it was op eggwars? You probably gapple chugged, everyone keeps saying gear is important on 1.8 but what everyone is forgetting is that gaps get you from half a heart to full in 2 seconds. On 1.9 it's so much easier to win 2v1s it gives you an advantage really, all their teammates are blocking their hits and having to wait a year and a half for their weapon to recharge, so what if gear plays a major factor or not? It should be part of your strategy to get as good gear as possible to win, or maybe this is all cuz your good at 1.9 and crap at 1.8.

 

[Qin Shihuangdi]

What 20 cps glitch, I'll have you know that anything divisible by 2 does max dps in 1.8

I'm referring to blockhitting. When you constantly blockhit, eventually with varying CPS the Minecraft ticks will not align with your opponent and the damage immunity replacement made all that useless.
tl;dr blockhitting is useless unless you have
A. Very similar CPS to opponent
B. Exactly double that of them
C. Exceed Minecraft tick speed

have you know that anything divisible by 2 does max dps in 1.8, clicking faster (WHILE HITTING ALL THESE CLICKS) only reduces the knock back you take,

I don't like either version. They both need serious work, but I play 80% 1.8 and prefer 1.9

Also jittering can not cause arthritis, arthritis is only caused by external sources such as jack hammers. I am not going to talk about hit reg because I know next to nothing about it, all I know is 1.7 > 1.8.

Rheumatoid arthritis is an autoimmune disease set off by overexertion of joints. Jittering will do this super quickly if done repetitively, and due to all the irregular motion within your hands rheumatoid can indeed be caused by jittering. People diagnosed with rheumatoid have a 6 year shorter life expectancy.

 

[Deeds]

You probably gapple chugged

Yes. Because I win fights while half the time eating gapples.
:/

Yeah I ate a few, but I didn’t chug them.

perhaps prot 4 since it was op eggwars

I love how you just assume that it’s OP eggwars.
Although you are correct, it was indeed in OP eggwars.
That really doesn’t chsnge anything though, I’ve handled tough situations in all modes.
It wasn’t really that hard though. I just came prepared and had a good game. My teammates couldn’t gove a crap to help me though so I had to try extra hard.

1.8 but what everyone is forgetting is that gaps get you from half a heart to full in 2 seconds.

I used gaps in my fight on 1.8. Guess what? It didn’t do crap. The only thing it did was help me stay alive for about an extra 10 seconds. In 1.8, you get destroyed really easily if you’re out-geared.

good at 1.9 and crap good at 1.8.

Naw bro.
I grind ranked skywars on l0pikel everyday, killing so called “pros”.
OP eggwars with full leather v. full iron is a completely different story though.
You literally have a .000001% chance of winning

their teammates are blocking their hits and having to wait a year and a half for their weapon to recharge, so what if gear plays a major factor or not?

Wow! Newsflash!
I have to wait 6 months also to recharge my weapon, but I actually manage. So did they. I was just more accurate with my hits. All about strategy in 1.9. Gear plays a small role, but if you play it right it doesn’t reslly matter.

What the heck are you on about.

 

[Mecha_San]

In 1.9, it's about timing hits. If you miss a hit and the other person hits you, the chances are different, or if you hit to early you do less damage. This opens up the chances of winning a battle for someone with less armor or a worse sword, because it's now about timing your hits, as where with 1.8 every hit did damage no matter the time in between, so someone with better armor wouldn't need to do as much to kill someone with worse gear.

Please explain 'pot pvp'.

In pot pvp, you need to constantly look at your health and make sure you don't throw your pots around randomly and heal your opponent. Not just that, you also need to repot your speed and eat food. You also have to try to kill someone quickly in pot pvp. This could kind of apply to cube crafts pot pvp. But the thing that makes cube craftspot pvp less skilled then 1.8 pot pvp is that you have to be a lot more aware of your health then on cube crafts pot pvp and sorry if I'm repeating this. Anyways, I still think both are skilled. Before I go on, I need to ask, when you say a person with better gear is fighting a guy with worse gear, the guy with better gear doesn't need to do as much work as a person in 1.9, are you still saying that 1.8 is less skilled then 1.9? If so, in ready to tell you or others about another gamemode that requires skill in 1.8, bit not much in 1.9.

 

[Mecha_San]

Yes. It is indeed.
Unlike 1.9, I don’t need to rely on whether I can rod people or not. Nor do I have to realy on who has the better weapon or sword.

1.8: Armour + Sword = Win
1.9: Armour + Sword = IT DOESN’T MATTER
I have 3v1’ed people in full iron, while in full leather. Just gotta say I kicked their butts.
In 1.8 I did the same thing, except it was a 2v1. I got my butt kicked.

In 1.8 it’s mainly the armour/weapons. CPS also plays a factor, the faster the better.
In 1.9 it’s mainly about skill and timing of hits. CPS doesn’t matter one bit.


View attachment 140067

Maybe your more skilled in 1.9 then in 1.8. You never know.

 

[Edgeless]

What's so funny? He's absolutely right, 1.8 is based entirely around who has the better gear, while 1.9 have a more fair and skilled pvp.

Does not I can combo a full diamond with no armour and kill him that what you said is completely false

 

[Max ♠]

1.8: Armour + Sword = Win
In 1.8 it’s mainly the armour/weapons.

 

[Troublesomee]

I think they have to keep the server up to date by switching to 1.14 when it is released. Though, why not? Why not give the players who like 1.8 more the opportunity to play other game modes? Let's all not discuss about the hit detection and the animations. I think it might attract players if more games will be 1.8. There will be no harm in adding it. If it costs a lot of effort to the developers, I will disagree.

 

[Miauw]

I believe 1.8 requires a fair amount of skill as well. Your Clicks per second, aiming, keys, hotbar selecting etc. Now it's true that Minecraft doesn't revolve around pure skill, there's also quite a bit of stragety and luck involved, but that's what makes it fun in my opinion.

 

[AFreakingCookie (Hank)]

Title says it all. Better hitboxes, hit detection, blockhitting, better animations and more. Not saying 1.8 pvp is better (Even though I think it is).

I think this would be great. PvP starts somewhere and duels for players in 1.8 would be great to see!
+1

 

[A pigeon]

IF they do this you’ll need to be content with downgraded and less pretty maps, since they’ll be edited into 1.8.

1.14 also needs to be added alongside , I saw chuck the versions inbetween

 

[OnePointEight.exe]

IF they do this you’ll need to be content with downgraded and less pretty maps, since they’ll be edited into 1.8.

1.14 also needs to be added alongside , I saw chuck the versions inbetween

Or they can use blocks that look good that translates between the two, in the 1.8 eggs lobby the floor is ss and es rather than the 1.9 chiseled es and sandstone. Same can be done with concrete and hardened clay.

 

[A pigeon]

Or they can use blocks that look good that translates between the two, in the 1.8 eggs lobby the floor is ss and es rather than the 1.9 chiseled es and sandstone. Same can be done with concrete and hardened clay.

Thats what I said , they’d look uglier translared into 1.8.

I mean , if the build team can build maps for both cersions then why is management so hesitant to remove 1.9 and add 1.14?

 

[A pigeon]

Why ask for 1.8 here anyway???? There are a million other servers! Whatever. What we need is both 1.8 and 1.14. No point in keeping 1.9-12. They should update.