Suggestion about Anti-Cheat

[The Crowbar]

Ok, I personally think that unless a player was falsely banned, the ban should be final. No sob stories or begging should change the fact that the player blatantly broke the rules. They should have to serve out the punishment.

I agree. But it isn't fair giving some players a chance. and not giving others a chance

 

[Thaus]

I agree. But it isn't fair giving some players a chance. and not giving others a chance

Wait are you guys saying that the perfect version of an anti cheat will ban?

 

[The Crowbar]

Wait are you guys saying that the perfect version of an anti cheat will ban?

1. It should. I think it would, like mineplex and hypixel.
2. If it doesn't hackers don't get kicked very often now, so....

 

[Thaus]

1. It should. I think it would, like mineplex and hypixel.
2. If it doesn't hackers don't get kicked very often now, so....

1. It's not going to happen. Ever. Period
2. True but remember that it is the beta version, and the devastating are working on it too.

 

[Qin Shihuangdi]

DO YOU EVEN KNOW HOW MANY PEOPLE HAVE BEEN FALSE BANNED BY WATCHDOG.
nothing more needed

 

[The Crowbar]

DO YOU EVEN KNOW HOW MANY PEOPLE HAVE BEEN FALSE BANNED BY WATCHDOG.
nothing more needed

I'm not saying to get watchdog. They've been working for so long, I tink that anti cheat is going to amazing at banning the correct people

 

[Thaus]

I'm not saying to get watchdog. They've been working for so long, I tink that anti cheat is going to amazing at banning the correct people

False. If mods cannot they how can you expect the anti cheat to? It should kick and only that. Nothing else.

 

[The Crowbar]

False. If mods cannot they how can you expect the anti cheat to? It should kick and only that. Nothing else.

Yes you can...... mods are just humans. They make mistakes. Computers don't make those mistakes

 

[Thaus]

Yes you can...... mods are just humans. They make mistakes. Computers don't make those mistakes

@zDutchie
Computers do make mistakes. It's called a BUG!
What you are trying to say won't work or will work. No anti cheat is perfect
and people may be banned because of lag. Tagged a mod to see if she agrees
that the anti cheat should ban people.

 

[The Crowbar]

@zDutchie
Computers do make mistakes. It's called a BUG!
What you are trying to say won't work or will work. No anti cheat is perfect
and people may be banned because of lag. Tagged a mod to see if she agrees
that the anti cheat should ban people.

Well, at least they should try. If it bans too many innocent people, they will remove it.

 

[Thaus]

Well, at least they should try. If it bans too many innocent people, they will remove it.

Nope. Better safe then sorry. Same with the mods. If it suspicious but not too clear, they usually don't ban the user because,"It's better to be safe than sorry!" (Talking about hacker reports.)

 

[The Crowbar]

Nope. Better safe then sorry. Same with the mods. If it suspicious but not too clear, they usually don't ban the user because,"It's better to be safe than sorry!"

Ok fine. It bans you if you were kicked three times in an hour?

 

[Thaus]

Ok fine. It bans you if you were kicked three times in an hour?

It could still be a false kick.
@TheJeroen can tell you this mate.

 

[The Crowbar]

It could still be a false kick.
@TheJeroen can tell you this mate.

I said THREE kicks. That CAN'T be an accident.

 

[Lezappen]

Nobody really cares about the complaints nearly as much as they do about the AC, trust me. And like I said, the announcement will be out. My friend hacked until he got banned (totally deserved it). He said that the anti cheat only kicks you. I think it should ban you for a: month, then permanently period.

Some people would get false banned, and since there is no way to distinguish a real hacker from someone who has been false banned via an unban appeal (as both appeals would be the same) we would have to accept the appeals of people being "False Banned" also a major inconvenience for good players who often trigger the anticheat.
One thing for sure is that hackers get kicked more often than good players, since this is the case the kicking stops their game allowing other players to continue without them. When they get tired of being kicked from every game they may eventually stop.

 

[zDutchie]

Well, at least they should try. If it bans too many innocent people, they will remove it.

We won't take that risk. Something like that has to work 100% or it will not be implemented.

 

[The Crowbar]

We won't take that risk. Something like that has to work 100% or it will not be implemented.

Some people would get false banned, and since there is no way to distinguish a real hacker from someone who has been false banned via an unban appeal (as both appeals would be the same) we would have to accept the appeals of people being "False Banned" also a major inconvenience for good players who often trigger the anticheat.
One thing for sure is that hackers get kicked more often than good players, since this is the case the kicking stops their game allowing other players to continue without them. When they get tired of being kicked from every game they may eventually stop.

Okay, Okay, fine. But after 3 kicks in like 30 minutes or something they should get banned

 

[Its_Veeds]

I actually like this idea ;)

Ayy dood u change your signture now your not a sad stone rank xD gg lol

 

[zDutchie]

Okay, Okay, fine. But after 3 kicks in like 30 minutes or something they should get banned

No.
Getting kicked 3 times still doesn't mean that you are using hacks.

 

[The Crowbar]

No.
Getting kicked 3 times still doesn't mean that you are using hacks.

Fine. You guys should make sure that it kicks hackers much more than it does know. Also, what do you think of the suggestion itself?