All Networks Cross-server play?

[Hazard]

This is mainly a suggestion for @Zed

With CubeCraft introducing new members of the team from NukkitX, Geyser, and DragonProxy, does that mean there is potential that we will see the ability to connect to Cubecraft Java through Bedrock Edition in the future? If this is so, it would be great to see the ability for all the Java server games to be ported over to allow Bedrock player support. Hopefully Microsoft would allow a partnered server to do something like this.

(Please move this topic to the correct discussion thread if needed)

 

[Axyy]

Don't think that's possible

 

[Hazard]

Don't think that's possible

Believe it or not, a Minecraft server on Bedrock called BrokenLens actually supports cross-client play. I only just found this out myself the other day. I'm sure this is something that CubeCraft might have noticed as well, otherwise, they wouldn't have been joining up with Geyser or DragonProxy developers.

Geyser:
Enable clients from Minecraft Bedrock Edition to join your Minecraft Java server.

DragonProxy:
A proxy to allow Minecraft: Bedrock clients to connect to Minecraft: Java Edition servers.

 

[DrHam]

Don't think that's possible

Yes, its posible. Indeed, they are already running Spigot (or a fork) on the Bedrock edition server.

It's hard, but possible

 

[AlperenKuru]

I’m confused, are you saying that Java and Bedrock players would play together?

 

[DrHam]

I’m confused, are you saying that Java and Bedrock players would play together?

Yes. Believe or it not, it’s possible

 

[AlperenKuru]

I think there are plenty of ways this can be beneficial or harmful. If I am understanding this correctly, it would mean keyboard and mouse players playing with mobile and or controller players, which is no way fair at all. A benefit would be that the server moderation would ‘increase’, one because moderators will be able to moderate both platforms and second because i’m assuming Sentinel would be updated together on both platforms (once they have a set anti-cheat dev). Like I said, the harm would be the unfairness of controllers vs keyboard and mouse vs mobile.

 

[Hazard]

I’m confused, are you saying that Java and Bedrock players would play together?

That is correct.

 

[Hazard]

I think there are plenty of ways this can be beneficial or harmful. If I am understanding this correctly, it would mean keyboard and mouse players playing with mobile and or controller players, which is no way fair at all. A benefit would be that the server moderation would ‘increase’, one because moderators will be able to moderate both platforms and second because i’m assuming Sentinel would be updated together on both platforms (once they have a set anti-cheat dev). Like I said, the harm would be the unfairness of controllers vs keyboard and mouse vs mobile.

That is correct, although this is a system that already exists on Bedrock Edition with Windows 10 Edition players. Keyboard and mouse Vs Mobile is something has been taking place for a while since Bedrock allowed Windows 10 Edition to play partnered servers and more.

 

[AlperenKuru]

That is correct, although this is a system that already exists on Bedrock Edition with Windows 10 Edition players. Keyboard and mouse Vs Mobile is something has been taking place for a while since Bedrock allowed Windows 10 Edition to play partnered servers and more.

That is stupid... and unfair..?

 

[Hazard]

That is stupid... and unfair..?

Well, I am sure there will be some measures in place by the developers since the new developers have a lot of experience in cross-client play.

 

[_EliteDevil]

I don't think this would be fair for the bedrock players, playing with keyboard and mouse is way easier than playing with controller or mobile.

 

[DrHam]

I don't think this would be fair for the bedrock players, playing with keyboard and mouse is way easier than playing with controller or mobile.

Tell that to Mojang. That already happens on Bedrock (Win 10 vs Mobile Editions)

 

[Lime]

It looks interesting at first, but if you think about it a little bit longer, you might realize that it isn’t that good of an idea. Because how would the connection between Java and Bedrock effect both platforms? Will we be playing 1.8 type of PvP again? And what about the Marketplace on Bedrock and the ranks on Java? Will we still keep them if both platforms were connected?
Currently, the amount of keyboard and mouse users on Bedrock is, as far as I know, still low. Connecting both platforms will make it highly unfair for those who play on their phones and with controllers. For these reasons, I think Bedrock and Java should stay separated.

 

[Dhafra]

Hey,
I do not agree with this idea because most of bedrock players are mobile and most of them are not that good, so it will be unfair for them to just invite the JAVA players who play on PC just to sweat on Mobile players, it would make Cubecraft more hated on the Mobile Community

 

[DrHam]

And what about the Marketplace on Bedrock and the ranks on Java? Will we still keep them if both platforms were connected?

What makes you think otherwise?

Will we be playing 1.8 type of PvP again?

there’s a 1.8 version of the network...

Hey,
I do not agree with this idea because most of bedrock players are mobile and most of them are not that good, so it will be unfair for them to just invite the JAVA players who play on PC just to sweat on Mobile players, it would make Cubecraft more hated on the Mobile Community

Again, it already happens with the Windows 10 edition

 

[Zed]

Hey - although in theory it's possible - for compliance and safety reasons we keep those authenticated with Xbox Live completely segregated and we can't change that.

 

[DevAwsome1]

This is would be completely unfair for xbox live players. First, java cubecraft and bedrock cubecraft are so much different. Java kids can use keyboards while bedrock kids are kinda stuck with controllers. I understand you can play bedrock on pc, but bedrock kids would get mega combo'd.

 

[DrHam]

for compliance and safety reasons

Why, if I can ask?

 

[DevAwsome1]

Why, if I can ask?

because through sterotypes, xbox kids say bad words 0_0 (probably not the

reason)