I'm 50 50 on this. This would be fun but all I see is just 100% camping. Why? Because people would be scared to attack at all because of bows, etc. In most cases, people might not even bridge to other islands. In skyward, you have to attack to get more loot to win. In EW, you can camp forever and still get more resources. Campers will be harder to face and the game might go on longer if not everyone is eliminated in the beginning. Plus, if this ever got implemented, there would be no chance for teams that did not get any diamonds at all unlike the current way. Once someone gets good gear, no one would even try to pvp to risk getting implemented. I don't really think that it's a good idea as you could just rush other teams in the beginning of the game to help make the game go faster. The good point about this is that it may add a new aspect towards EW but it may create some intense camping since you have 1 life.