Bedrock multiple bedrock report changes

[Felinesheep1982]

1. it is impossible to report macros and auto clickers without hearing hit sounds, add them back.

2. players should be able to report people with a video that the person who is being reported made (the POV of the person youre reporting). this change was made because you can't verify how old the video is, but i could record someone, and upload it to youtube a month later and you wouldn't ever know it was a month old.

3. with the change above, you should also accept reports that are showing 20+ cps on keystroke overlays.

4. evidence should not be required for username reports as all the mod does is look at the name and decide if its allowed or not.

5. mods should be required to say why a report was denied rather than just the "im so sorry your report was denied its not enough evidence thanks for reporting" bot-like message they send.

 

[a random cubecraft player]

all of them would be nice

 

[GiGaGekkies]

Haiii!

1. it is impossible to report macros and auto clickers without hearing hit sounds, add them back.

I disagree with this because I always use an autoclicker and this change would make that impossible. All jokes aside, I definitely agree with this one, because this was a really good one for reporting and pvp is super boring and empty without these sounds.

2. players should be able to report people with a video that the person who is being reported made (the POV of the person youre reporting). this change was made because you can't verify how old the video is, but i could record someone, and upload it to youtube a month later and you wouldn't ever know it was a month old.

You can't verify how old a video is if it's reuploaded, so I totally disagree with this one, sorry. Yes, ofcourse they are able to appeal, but they would probably get many appeals claiming that this video is older than the allowed date. They would waste a lot of time with this, so it's better to avoid it.

3. with the change above, you should also accept reports that are showing 20+ cps on keystroke overlays.

No, no and no! I really disagree with this one, because there are clicking methods which allows you to click with over 20+ cps. Ofcourse, there are many people who don't do this legit, but I don't think that's a valid reason to implement this.

4. evidence should not be required for username reports as all the mod does is look at the name and decide if its allowed or not.

I totally agree with this one, but unfortunately this is impossible to implement. You can find CapitanGato's message about it here! However, I'm pretty sure you are able to submit a black screen/random picture, so you should do that instead. This also counts for skin reports though.

5. mods should be required to say why a report was denied rather than just the "im so sorry your report was denied its not enough evidence thanks for reporting" bot-like message they send.

Yep, I really like this idea and it would be very useful to know why your report was denied. This would help you improve reporting, so that you'll become a report pro :)

I agree with 3 of them and I disagree with 2 of them, so that's why I'm unsure. However, it's a very good suggestion! Keep up the good work <3!

Disclaimer: I haven't used the bedrock report site yet, so I could be wrong with my answers. Please correct me if I'm wrong, thankss :)

 

[Landon AWESOME9]

You can't verify how old a video is if it's reuploaded, so I totally disagree with this one, sorry. Yes, ofcourse they are able to appeal, but they would probably get many appeals claiming that this video is older than the allowed date. They would waste a lot of time with this, so it's better to avoid it.

The same could be said about videos taken to report someone, so I think if someone cheats in a video they uploaded the time frame should be increased, especially since they probably uploaded the video knowing they cheated.

On your overlay claim I disagree with using the overlay to determine cps since they can be easily faked, but 20cps is about as high as "legit" is.

 

[Landon AWESOME9]

bump

 

[DarkStray]

1. it is impossible to report macros and auto clickers without hearing hit sounds, add them back.

No point of removing them when it's literally easier to add a FREE resource pack to fix this.
So Agreed

2. players should be able to report people with a video that the person who is being reported made (the POV of the person youre reporting). this change was made because you can't verify how old the video is, but i could record someone, and upload it to youtube a month later and you wouldn't ever know it was a month old.

Agreed, there is no date in the scoreboard like some other servers do.
Also Yea you can just upload the video later, but there is also a way to tell by the media file name. But mods aren't smart enough to spot a date on a screenshot so who knows...

3. with the change above, you should also accept reports that are showing 20+ cps on keystroke overlays.

Literally impossible without doubles or a macro/firekey

4. evidence should not be required for username reports as all the mod does is look at the name and decide if its allowed or not.

Yea

5. mods should be required to say why a report was denied rather than just the "im so sorry your report was denied its not enough evidence thanks for reporting" bot-like message they send.

Yea agreed.

 

[DarkStray]

No, no and no! I really disagree with this one, because there are clicking methods which allows you to click with over 20+ cps. Ofcourse, there are many people who don't do this legit, but I don't think that's a valid reason to implement this.

Okay maybe your right

Drag Clicking
Macros/autoclickers
Butterfly+Doubles
Jitter(possibly)

3/4 which are cheating by CC rules
And he said by their own video, but while jitterclicking you would see a very visible screenshake


so I have to agree with the OP

You can't verify how old a video is if it's reuploaded, so I totally disagree with this one, sorry. Yes, ofcourse they are able to appeal, but they would probably get many appeals claiming that this video is older than the allowed date. They would waste a lot of time with this, so it's better to avoid it.

You can check file names on videos

 

[Landon AWESOME9]

Okay maybe your right

Drag Clicking
Macros/autoclickers
Butterfly+Doubles
Jitter(possibly)

3/4 which are cheating by CC rules
And he said by their own video, but while jitterclicking you would see a very visible screenshake


so I have to agree with the OP

You can check file names on videos
View attachment 203587

You could check file names though they could be faked, or you could yk not upload yourself cheating in the first place kinda simple to me idk about others

 

[Felinesheep1982]

Okay maybe your right

Drag Clicking
Macros/autoclickers
Butterfly+Doubles
Jitter(possibly)

3/4 which are cheating by CC rules
And he said by their own video, but while jitterclicking you would see a very visible screenshake


so I have to agree with the OP

You can check file names on videos
View attachment 203587

but i could upload something that i clipped 2 months ago and put it on youtube and itll get accepted so theres no point of not allowing us to report other peoples videos

 

[Pineapple]

1. it is impossible to report macros and auto clickers without hearing hit sounds, add them back.

Agreed, not much more to say really. This has already been forwarded though.

2. players should be able to report people with a video that the person who is being reported made (the POV of the person youre reporting). this change was made because you can't verify how old the video is, but i could record someone, and upload it to youtube a month later and you wouldn't ever know it was a month old.

This is already allowed.

3. with the change above, you should also accept reports that are showing 20+ cps on keystroke overlays.

20+ CPS isn’t really possible without using an illegal clicking method or modifying your debounce. So pretty much also already a thing xd.

4. evidence should not be required for username reports as all the mod does is look at the name and decide if its allowed or not.

This is already the case.

5. mods should be required to say why a report was denied rather than just the "im so sorry your report was denied its not enough evidence thanks for reporting" bot-like message they send.

Insufficient evidence is a reason though? Not really sure what you mean here, this is pretty much also already the case.

 

[Felinesheep1982]

Insufficient evidence is a reason though? Not really sure what you mean here, this is pretty much also already the case.

like if it doesnt show a macro for long enough, it doesn't look fast enough, kill aura looks like it's just lag, one time i reported someones own video where they were getting 25 cps and it got denied twice by modulo for "insufficient evidence" so i asked in staff help and it turns out they dont accept videos taken by the player youre reporting because they cant verify the age of the video, it wouldve helped to know that instead of just denying it.

 

[DarkStray]

like if it doesnt show a macro for long enough, it doesn't look fast enough, kill aura looks like it's just lag, one time i reported someones own video where they were getting 25 cps and it got denied twice by modulo for "insufficient evidence" so i asked in staff help and it turns out they dont accept videos taken by the player youre reporting because they cant verify the age of the video, it wouldve helped to know that instead of just denying it.

Who as the player and how long ago was this?

 

[a random cubecraft player]

Okay maybe your right

Drag Clicking
Macros/autoclickers
Butterfly+Doubles
Jitter(possibly)

3/4 which are cheating by CC rules
And he said by their own video, but while jitterclicking you would see a very visible screenshake


so I have to agree with the OP

You can check file names on videos
View attachment 203587

i is also possible to butterfly without doubles close to 20 but not exactly i disagree with double clicks being bannable but its the rules ig

 

[Felinesheep1982]

i is also possible to butterfly without doubles close to 20 but not exactly i disagree with double clicks being bannable but its the rules ig

double clicks should be bannable because its literally fake cps and not all mice double click

 

[Landon AWESOME9]

double clicks should be bannable because its literally fake cps and not all mice double click

it creates a p2w or cheat to win game style

 

[Felinesheep1982]

bump

 

[BurntCrown8876]

It got a bit easier to report, now you can report in game on Bedrock, rather than having to make a huge and very complicated report on the forums. Now you can use /Sr, but I agree woth all 5 of these changes.

 

[Felinesheep1982]

It got a bit easier to report, now you can report in game on Bedrock, rather than having to make a huge and very complicated report on the forums. Now you can use /Sr, but I agree woth all 5 of these changes.

/sr works less than 1% of the time because of the lack of mods on the server

 

[a random cubecraft player]

/sr works less than 1% of the time because of the lack of mods on the server

true

 

[Dont kill]

/sr works less than 1% of the time because of the lack of mods on the server

That is 100% true

I used /sr more than 450 times and only 2 players got ban :(