D
The map is surely good and has a lot of potential, I voted no because you can still improve the map in its details to make it as perfect as possible.
View attachment 164081
I'd suggest to fix the trees: there are some floating blocks and the bottom is 3 blocks wide and then gets to 1 block wide too soon, you should make the tree a bit fatter, if you look at the base it doesnt look really realistic.
Another thing I'd change is the bridge: instead of placing 3 blocks and 1 slab, place 2 blocks and 2 slabs to give it a straight shape and I think it would be better for the pvp as well.
View attachment 164082
In the starter island I dont really like the outisde design of the house/temple: it looks like a mixture of both structures, I'd suggest making the roof bigger, as the oriental temples have . another thing I dont like are the random podzol blocks placed like that, I'd remove them. Then the tree has 2 branches without leaves and I dont get the reason.
Dont take this comment as too judgy, I've been a builder for years and I just wanna help you to improve the map since it's probably gonna be added.
Anyways, well done and keep up the good work.
Same, I'd love playing this mapim actually obsessed with this map