After testing out the new games, I will have to agree with this. Arcade would have worked better without this massive revamp.
Even though some of the new games are fun, they don't have the same feeling as the old games. The arcade was, for me, a place to come and play quick, fun and simple games. Some of the games there were really fun. Imo, they were, in their simplicity, better than most new ones. Take TNTrun. It was about running, jumping and making sure not to fall down. Simple. Now, with the new layer spleef, a mix of other similar games have also been added. The result of this is just a massive mess. There's no need to fix anything that isn't broken. The spleef would have been better if this was added as a new mode. We already had a few that let us select what we preferred, so why not just add another one like that?
The next game on the list is Paintball. This is one of the few games I like the update to. However, I have also noticed a gamemode was removed. Why did you remove the CTF part of it? It was a lot of fun, and had potential to get updated to something amazing. Another thing that needs a change is the spawn area. I have, on multiple occasions, been stuck in spawn because people have camped behind the walls, shooting into the spawn area. The spawn protection doesn't protect us enough to let us get out. Though, the positives outweigh the negatives. Good job on this one.
Ok, the next game is Barn Brawl. This is a game that might be fun for five minutes, but it gets boring quick. After less than a round of it, you get bored. There's not much more to be said here. Instead, I will go directly to the next game, Line Dash. It is a game that is oddly similar to Snowdown, a game I love. Though, it has become something that feels a little off. It might be that there are too many teams, or maybe the fact that you need a powerup to jump. Whatever it is, it's something that shouldn't be there.
Last but not least, Wing Rush. This one is fun, but I feel like a game like this should have more than two maps. It didn't even take me an hour to learn a strat that makes me win 4/5 times.
I would not like to see these games discarded. Some of them are still really fun. The thing I would do is simply adding the old arcade games as a Classic Arcade lobby. This would allow players to play the old games and the new ones. Just look at the numbers in the voting. They don't lie.