All Networks [PART 2] 10 Ideas & Changes for Lucky Islands☘️💱🌈!

[Velocidad]

Hey! We're back with the second part of this thread, If you haven't read it yet, I recommend doing so and then you can continue with this one. In this second part brought by @shamomshka and I, most of them are ideas since in the previous thread was where the changes that we believed were best and necessary were exposed, we could have added more changes but they seemed irrelevant and uninteresting to us. As in the previous thread I have left the best or at least my favorite of all the ideas for last, it is not as complex and elaborate as the glitched lucky blocks but I still think it is a very fun idea.

This ideas and changes are thought from a Java point of view, meaning that some things may not be compatible or necessary in Bedrock.

- The drop of the mob eggs now are not hostile to the one who spawns them, the mobs will atack only other users. + More diversity of eggs .


- Ender Sword, an iron sword with sharpness 1 and themed in purple so people can tell which sword it is, with this sword by right clicking you can teleport 3 blocks of distance in front of where you are aiming with a 20 second delay

Spoiler: Sketch of the Ender Sword

- Disabler wand, with this wand the people in a radius of 5x5x4 can't use bows,crossbows,wands etc. Basically you cant use the right click,The radius will be shown like the swapper wand but they will be red particles instead of purple. This wand has a delay of 1 minute, the radius will last 10 seconds, if you exit the radius while the effect is still active you will continue to be affected by the effect for 3 more seconds. The design I had in mind for this wand was a red wand with a barrier block on top.

- Treasure map, if you get it, somewhere on the map spawns a barrel inside of the ground,The loot will be slightly better than what usually appears in the chests where armor always appears + a golden apple always appears 100% of the time.



- Add Cloud Boots, white leather boots with feather falling 4

- The Heart of Destiny, A heart that can save or ruin your game, it carries a great risk but the benefits are worth that risk, as its name says everything is in the hands of fate, special item that give you instantly 5 hearts but removes 2 hearts permanently so instead of having 20hp will fulll hearts you have 16hp but there is a probability(50%) that can kill you instantly.

Spoiler: The Heart of Destiny

-Defective potion, Failed product of an alchemist, use at your own risk, potion(no splash) with nausea 1, poison 1, speed 1, hunger 1 and strenght 1 for 15-20 seconds


- Add "Blowguns", when you get the bamboo + sticks + sugarcane drop you got now a low probability of getting a blowgun from bamboos, this blowgun is of 1 use and shot and arrow of poison 1 of 5/10 secs. The custom animation would be like when you shot with a crossbow.

Spoiler: Blowgun + video

The video is just for a visual example, but I don't like the animation of the blowgun and the firing of the arrow shown in the video.

- Luck Stick, a stick blessed by the god of luck, this stick have a random level 7 enchantment

Before introducing and defining the idea I wanted to give a little context of where the inspiration comes from, a few weeks ago I was reading a fantasy manga, in this manga one of the most characteristic monsters are frogs and when entering dungeons there is a very rare probability that a golden frog will appear, The golden frog is basically a winning lottery ticket, and I won't tell you more because you will understand everything once I explain it in detail.



The idea would be that there is a drop where mostly normal frogs appear(in very rare cases, instead of a normal frog, a Golden Frog will appear...) without anything special, except their drops that with a low probability can give you Frog Slime.

The frog slime would be an enchanted slimeball, it would be a projectile like a snowball, when hitting an enemy it will be affected by slowness 1 + it will walk as if it were on top of slime blocks for 5 seconds.

Spoiler: Frog Slime

Golden Frogs are a very rare mutation of normal frogs, they have a very low probability of appearing, once they appear they will flee from players since these frogs have a higher intelligence than normal ones and knows that humans covet its golden color a lot, if you kill it some of its possible drops are a totem or a notch. But it is not that simple since apart from fleeing from players they are also immune to all types of projectiles or damage not done by tools like the sword or the axe, meaning you will have to hunt it by cornering the frog or using other clever strategies that might surprise the Golden Frog.

Those of you who have played Super Mario 64 will be very familiar with the idea of the Golden Frog, since in this game you had to catch a golden rabbit that was running away from Mario in order to obtain a star. I suppose the author of the manga was inspired to some extent by this idea.

Spoiler: Golden Frog

Spoiler: Manga where the idea comes from

Spoiler: Video of the golden rabbit (Super Mario 64)

In the end, these are simply ideas and changes that we would like to see in the game, but we understand that not all ideas will be accepted or that people may not like them. If there is something that you don't understand, does not convince you or that you would make some change, do not hesitate to say so.

If we get to 20 positive reactions , @shamomshka and I might consider making a part 3 or a bonus/extra part(a part where its more free and not too serious, just all the wild ideas we have), but it wouldn't be 100% certain since we've already used most of our best ideas and changes, meaning it would take us some time to be able to gather enough quality ideas to be able to make another thread.

Thank you for reading all the thread

Spoiler: <3

And again thanks sham for helping in the whole process of this thread

 

[Fjackp14_]

- The drop of the mob eggs now are not hostile to the one who spawns them, the mobs will atack only other users. + More diversity of eggs .

️ I totally agree with that bc getting the blaze one is soooo annoying if u don't have water bucket and/or weapon to fend it off

Ender Sword, an iron sword with sharpness 1 and themed in purple so people can tell which sword it is, with this sword by right clicking you can teleport 3 blocks of distance in front of where you are aiming with a 20 second delay

Spoiler: Sketch of the Ender Sword

undefined

Basically a little less op e pearl. ️

Disabler wand, with this wand the people in a radius of 5x5x4 can't use bows,crossbows,wands etc. Basically you cant use the right click,The radius will be shown like the swapper wand but they will be red particles instead of purple. This wand has a delay of 1 minute, the radius will last 10 seconds, if you exit the radius while the effect is still active you will continue to be affected by the effect for 3 more seconds. The design I had in mind for this wand was a red wand with a barrier block on top.

I agree with this but when you say they can't right click does that mean they can't place blocks or eat either?

Treasure map, if you get it, somewhere on the map spawns a barrel inside of the ground,The loot will be slightly better than what usually appears in the chests where armor always appears + a golden apple always appears 100% of the time.

Add Cloud Boots, white leather boots with feather falling 4

Too op, feather falling 2 or 3 would be much better

- The Heart of Destiny, A heart that can save or ruin your game, it carries a great risk but the benefits are worth that risk, as its name says everything is in the hands of fate, special item that give you instantly 5 hearts but removes 2 hearts permanently so instead of having 20hp will fulll hearts you have 16hp but there is a probability(50%) that can kill you instantly.

Agree with everything here apart from 50% chance to kill you. I think 30 or 35% would be more balanced

Defective potion, Failed product of an alchemist, use at your own risk, potion with nausea 1, poison 1, speed 1, hunger 1 and strenght 1 for 15-20 seconds

️

Add "Blowguns", when you get the bamboo + sticks + sugarcane drop you got now a low probability of getting a blowgun from bamboos, this blowgun is of 1 use and shot and arrow of poison 1 of 5/10 secs. The custom animation would be like when you shot with a crossbow.

The main reason I agree with this one is bc that drop is kinda just pointless. ️

Luck Stick, a stick blessed by the god of luck, this stick have a random level 7 enchantment

Ooh that's a nice idea I like it ️ could be a little bit unbalanced but it's fine.

 

[TheMrSpacee]

Generally I aggre, but:

Disabler wand, with this wand the people in a radius of 5x5x4 can't use bows,crossbows,wands etc. Basically you cant use the right click,The radius will be shown like the swapper wand but they will be red particles instead of purple. This wand has a delay of 1 minute, the radius will last 10 seconds, if you exit the radius while the effect is still active you will continue to be affected by the effect for 3 more seconds. The design I had in mind for this wand was a red wand with a barrier block on top.

I can't imagine situation it would be useful in game

Defective potion, Failed product of an alchemist, use at your own risk, potion with nausea 1, poison 1, speed 1, hunger 1 and strenght 1 for 15-20 seconds

Potion wand.

Add "Blowguns", when you get the bamboo + sticks + sugarcane drop you got now a low probability of getting a blowgun from bamboos, this blowgun is of 1 use and shot and arrow of poison 1 of 5/10 secs. The custom animation would be like when you shot with a crossbow.

Bow and arrow with poison effect.

Golden Frogs

Good idea, but it shouldn't be frogs

 

[CrystalLegend01]

- The drop of the mob eggs now are not hostile to the one who spawns them, the mobs will atack only other users. + More diversity of eggs .​

This sounds like a decent change so I’ll go with

- Ender Sword, an iron sword with sharpness 1 and themed in purple so people can tell which sword it is, with this sword by right clicking you can teleport 3 blocks of distance in front of where you are aiming with a 20 second delay

Spoiler: Sketch of the Ender Sword

View attachment 236083

This is a neat idea, and the sketch looks cool

I’m slightly unsure about the 3-block range. Would it go where you click or would it send you 3 blocks in a direction? I could maybe see a few uses for it, like quickly teleporting onto a nearby ledge to gain some height, but I’m not sure how useful it would be horizontally. If it can be used to go through a wall (or possibly a floor) then that could be pretty handy

- Disabler wand, with this wand the people in a radius of 5x5x4 can't use bows,crossbows,wands etc. Basically you cant use the right click,The radius will be shown like the swapper wand but they will be red particles instead of purple. This wand has a delay of 1 minute, the radius will last 10 seconds, if you exit the radius while the effect is still active you will continue to be affected by the effect for 3 more seconds. The design I had in mind for this wand was a red wand with a barrier block on top.​

Considering that it can disable wands and other usable items, this sounds like it could be pretty useful

- Treasure map, if you get it, somewhere on the map spawns a barrel inside of the ground,The loot will be slightly better than what usually appears in the chests where armor always appears + a golden apple always appears 100% of the time.​

I love this idea! ^^

- Add Cloud Boots, white leather boots with feather falling 4​

I wouldn’t mind this one so I’m going with

If it’s implemented I think it should be uncommon or somewhat rare, probably in a Diamond Lucky Block

- The Heart of Destiny, A heart that can save or ruin your game, it carries a great risk but the benefits are worth that risk, as its name says everything is in the hands of fate, special item that give you instantly 5 hearts but removes 2 hearts permanently so instead of having 20hp will fulll hearts you have 16hp but there is a probability(50%) that can kill you instantly.

Spoiler: The Heart of Destiny

View attachment 236084

​

While this is a cool concept, I’m not sure about the 50% chance of instantly dying. It seems a bit too luck based and I think that it should be survivable in some way (while still being deadly)

I think it should give you the Wither effect, which can kill you if you don't quickly heal up or drink milk; maybe it could be Wither II or more so that it can somewhat quickly kill you, but there’s still a way to prevent it if you respond soon enough

-Defective potion, Failed product of an alchemist, use at your own risk, potion(no splash) with nausea 1, poison 1, speed 1, hunger 1 and strenght 1 for 15-20 seconds​

I think this is a good idea

It fits well with the randomness aspect of Lucky Islands

- Add "Blowguns", when you get the bamboo + sticks + sugarcane drop you got now a low probability of getting a blowgun from bamboos, this blowgun is of 1 use and shot and arrow of poison 1 of 5/10 secs. The custom animation would be like when you shot with a crossbow.

Spoiler: Blowgun + video

View attachment 236085

The video is just for a visual example, but I don't like the animation of the blowgun and the firing of the arrow shown in the video.

I wouldn’t mind seeing this in-game

- Luck Stick, a stick blessed by the god of luck, this stick have a random level 7 enchantment​

This fits well with the randomness aspect. I like how you could either get a useless enchantment or one that benefits you in some way

View attachment 236087

Before introducing and defining the idea I wanted to give a little context of where the inspiration comes from, a few weeks ago I was reading a fantasy manga, in this manga one of the most characteristic monsters are frogs and when entering dungeons there is a very rare probability that a golden frog will appear, The golden frog is basically a winning lottery ticket, and I won't tell you more because you will understand everything once I explain it in detail.



The idea would be that there is a drop where mostly normal frogs appear(in very rare cases, instead of a normal frog, a Golden Frog will appear...) without anything special, except their drops that with a low probability can give you Frog Slime.


View attachment 236088

The frog slime would be an enchanted slimeball, it would be a projectile like a snowball, when hitting an enemy it will be affected by slowness 1 + it will walk as if it were on top of slime blocks for 5 seconds.

Spoiler: Frog Slime

View attachment 236089

View attachment 236090


Golden Frogs are a very rare mutation of normal frogs, they have a very low probability of appearing, once they appear they will flee from players since these frogs have a higher intelligence than normal ones and knows that humans covet its golden color a lot, if you kill it some of its possible drops are a totem or a notch. But it is not that simple since apart from fleeing from players they are also immune to all types of projectiles or damage not done by tools like the sword or the axe, meaning you will have to hunt it by cornering the frog or using other clever strategies that might surprise the Golden Frog.

Those of you who have played Super Mario 64 will be very familiar with the idea of the Golden Frog, since in this game you had to catch a golden rabbit that was running away from Mario in order to obtain a star. I suppose the author of the manga was inspired to some extent by this idea.

Spoiler: Golden Frog

View attachment 236094

This is an interesting idea!

 

[coolzombiee]

This sounds like a decent change so I’ll go with

This is a neat idea, and the sketch looks cool

I’m slightly unsure about the 3-block range. Would it go where you click or would it send you 3 blocks in a direction? I could maybe see a few uses for it, like quickly teleporting onto a nearby ledge to gain some height, but I’m not sure how useful it would be horizontally. If it can be used to go through a wall (or possibly a floor) then that could be pretty handy

Considering that it can disable wands and other usable items, this sounds like it could be pretty useful

I love this idea! ^^

I wouldn’t mind this one so I’m going with

If it’s implemented I think it should be uncommon or somewhat rare, probably in a Diamond Lucky Block

While this is a cool concept, I’m not sure about the 50% chance of instantly dying. It seems a bit too luck based and I think that it should be survivable in some way (while still being deadly)

I think it should give you the Wither effect, which can kill you if you don't quickly heal up or drink milk; maybe it could be Wither II or more so that it can somewhat quickly kill you, but there’s still a way to prevent it if you respond soon enough

I think this is a good idea

It fits well with the randomness aspect of Lucky Islands

I wouldn’t mind seeing this in-game

This fits well with the randomness aspect. I like how you could either get a useless enchantment or one that benefits you in some way

This is an interesting idea!

I agree! Maybe they could instead of making it feather falling 4, it could be a effect that is there when it is worn, or there could be a potion of slow falling with it

 

[lorilambthecoolgamer]

View attachment 236079

Hey! We're back with the second part of this thread, If you haven't read it yet, I recommend doing so and then you can continue with this one. In this second part brought by @shamomshka and I, most of them are ideas since in the previous thread was where the changes that we believed were best and necessary were exposed, we could have added more changes but they seemed irrelevant and uninteresting to us. As in the previous thread I have left the best or at least my favorite of all the ideas for last, it is not as complex and elaborate as the glitched lucky blocks but I still think it is a very fun idea.

This ideas and changes are thought from a Java point of view, meaning that some things may not be compatible or necessary in Bedrock.

View attachment 236082

- The drop of the mob eggs now are not hostile to the one who spawns them, the mobs will atack only other users. + More diversity of eggs .


- Ender Sword, an iron sword with sharpness 1 and themed in purple so people can tell which sword it is, with this sword by right clicking you can teleport 3 blocks of distance in front of where you are aiming with a 20 second delay

Spoiler: Sketch of the Ender Sword

View attachment 236083

- Disabler wand, with this wand the people in a radius of 5x5x4 can't use bows,crossbows,wands etc. Basically you cant use the right click,The radius will be shown like the swapper wand but they will be red particles instead of purple. This wand has a delay of 1 minute, the radius will last 10 seconds, if you exit the radius while the effect is still active you will continue to be affected by the effect for 3 more seconds. The design I had in mind for this wand was a red wand with a barrier block on top.

- Treasure map, if you get it, somewhere on the map spawns a barrel inside of the ground,The loot will be slightly better than what usually appears in the chests where armor always appears + a golden apple always appears 100% of the time.



- Add Cloud Boots, white leather boots with feather falling 4

- The Heart of Destiny, A heart that can save or ruin your game, it carries a great risk but the benefits are worth that risk, as its name says everything is in the hands of fate, special item that give you instantly 5 hearts but removes 2 hearts permanently so instead of having 20hp will fulll hearts you have 16hp but there is a probability(50%) that can kill you instantly.

Spoiler: The Heart of Destiny

View attachment 236084

-Defective potion, Failed product of an alchemist, use at your own risk, potion(no splash) with nausea 1, poison 1, speed 1, hunger 1 and strenght 1 for 15-20 seconds


- Add "Blowguns", when you get the bamboo + sticks + sugarcane drop you got now a low probability of getting a blowgun from bamboos, this blowgun is of 1 use and shot and arrow of poison 1 of 5/10 secs. The custom animation would be like when you shot with a crossbow.

Spoiler: Blowgun + video

View attachment 236085

The video is just for a visual example, but I don't like the animation of the blowgun and the firing of the arrow shown in the video.

- Luck Stick, a stick blessed by the god of luck, this stick have a random level 7 enchantment




View attachment 236087

Before introducing and defining the idea I wanted to give a little context of where the inspiration comes from, a few weeks ago I was reading a fantasy manga, in this manga one of the most characteristic monsters are frogs and when entering dungeons there is a very rare probability that a golden frog will appear, The golden frog is basically a winning lottery ticket, and I won't tell you more because you will understand everything once I explain it in detail.



The idea would be that there is a drop where mostly normal frogs appear(in very rare cases, instead of a normal frog, a Golden Frog will appear...) without anything special, except their drops that with a low probability can give you Frog Slime.


View attachment 236088

The frog slime would be an enchanted slimeball, it would be a projectile like a snowball, when hitting an enemy it will be affected by slowness 1 + it will walk as if it were on top of slime blocks for 5 seconds.

Spoiler: Frog Slime

View attachment 236089

View attachment 236090


Golden Frogs are a very rare mutation of normal frogs, they have a very low probability of appearing, once they appear they will flee from players since these frogs have a higher intelligence than normal ones and knows that humans covet its golden color a lot, if you kill it some of its possible drops are a totem or a notch. But it is not that simple since apart from fleeing from players they are also immune to all types of projectiles or damage not done by tools like the sword or the axe, meaning you will have to hunt it by cornering the frog or using other clever strategies that might surprise the Golden Frog.

Those of you who have played Super Mario 64 will be very familiar with the idea of the Golden Frog, since in this game you had to catch a golden rabbit that was running away from Mario in order to obtain a star. I suppose the author of the manga was inspired to some extent by this idea.

Spoiler: Golden Frog

View attachment 236094

Spoiler: Manga where the idea comes from

View attachment 236095

Spoiler: Video of the golden rabbit (Super Mario 64)

View attachment 236096

In the end, these are simply ideas and changes that we would like to see in the game, but we understand that not all ideas will be accepted or that people may not like them. If there is something that you don't understand, does not convince you or that you would make some change, do not hesitate to say so.

If we get to 20 positive reactions , @shamomshka and I might consider making a part 3 or a bonus/extra part(a part where its more free and not too serious, just all the wild ideas we have), but it wouldn't be 100% certain since we've already used most of our best ideas and changes, meaning it would take us some time to be able to gather enough quality ideas to be able to make another thread.

Thank you for reading all the thread

Spoiler: <3

And again thanks sham for helping in the whole process of this thread

I really like to idea for the heart of destiny! (The other ideas are cool too) :)

 

[shamomshka]

Too op, feather falling 2 or 3 would be much better

Agree with everything here apart from 50% chance to kill you. I think 30 or 35% would be more balanced

Hey fionnjackp14! Thanks a lot for the Feedback! <3

Cloud Boots:
I totally understand your opinion on the Cloud Boots, we weren´t quite sure at first as well which level of Feather Falling it should have. Our Idea was that it should be strong boots like the Explosion Boots, you get Blast Prot 10 with it but they are leather boots. So if you have Diamond Boots or Iron Boots you have to choose which one is better. You are always trading Armour Bars for the Effect. The Cloud Boots will be Leather Boots as well and as rare as the Explosion Boots. So as I said, while Feather Falling 4 is pretty op its a trade for armour bars.
But I wouldnt mind them being Feather Falling 3 as well though :D

Heart of Destiny:
The Idea behind it is that it is a last resort Item. Not an Item you use without caution in a fight but something you would only consider when you are near Death anyways. So as the name suggests its you last chance of survival and if you are lucky you can turn around a fight with it or at least survive it. So I still think 50/50 is quite fitting for the Heart of Destiny.

Thanks again for the feedback I am happy you liked our ideas, if you have any questions or want to discuss it further feel free to do so :)

 

[shamomshka]

Generally I aggre, but:

I can't imagine situation it would be useful in game

Potion wand.

Bow and arrow with poison effect.

Good idea, but it shouldn't be frogs

Thanks for the Feedback :)

Disabler Wand:
How can you not imagine situations it would be useful in game? It means that the other person cant use any bows for example in that radius and few sec after leaving it as well, that alone is very useful.

Why no Frogs? :D You have another Idea? We would love to hear it then so we can think about.

Thanks again for the interest in our post <3

 

[Velocidad]

️ I totally agree with that bc getting the blaze one is soooo annoying if u don't have water bucket and/or weapon to fend it off

Here you have misunderstood the idea, in Java there is a drop in which they give you spider, skeleton or zombie eggs, the problem is that when you spawn them they are hostile to everyone, that is why we wanted to make that change. The Blaze drop, like so many others, aims to annoy the player while playing, but we believe that they are fine as they are.

I agree with this but when you say they can't right click does that mean they can't place blocks or eat either?

Exactly, You can neither eat nor place blocks, all right-click actions are disabled, for example, You would not be able to use the ender pearls or the shield while under the effect of the wand.

Could you talk about why you are not sure about this idea, or what change you would make to it?

I think this is a good idea

It fits well with the randomness aspect of Lucky Islands

Potion wand.

Here I think both of you have misunderstood, the idea is not to have a potion that when you drink it can give you one of the named effects, but that when you drink it, it will give you all those effects, in exchange for being able to have strength you will have many bad effects, but in specific situations it can be very useful.

btw @TheMrSpacee , This goes for all your answers, if you are going to make a criticism please elaborate in your answer and give the reasons why you do not like them or what changes you would make, thank you.

This is a neat idea, and the sketch looks cool

I’m slightly unsure about the 3-block range. Would it go where you click or would it send you 3 blocks in a direction? I could maybe see a few uses for it, like quickly teleporting onto a nearby ledge to gain some height, but I’m not sure how useful it would be horizontally. If it can be used to go through a wall (or possibly a floor) then that could be pretty handy

The mechanics of the sword are that it teleports you a distance of 3 blocks in the direction you are pointing(like the ice wand so that it is understood to a certain extent but without the limit of angles) and there is no need for there to be a block in order to teleport, that is, if you aim up and there is only air you will teleport 3 blocks above you and the same if you aim looking down but be careful because you could suffocate, in case it is horizontal it could be used to be able to go through walls or to get closer to your enemy faster when he is fleeing, or maybe to be able to flee when they are chasing you.

While this is a cool concept, I’m not sure about the 50% chance of instantly dying. It seems a bit too luck based and I think that it should be survivable in some way (while still being deadly)

I think it should give you the Wither effect, which can kill you if you don't quickly heal up or drink milk; maybe it could be Wither II or more so that it can somewhat quickly kill you, but there’s still a way to prevent it if you respond soon enough

The answer to this would be the one that shamomshka gave to fionnjackp14, but even so, the change you have proposed is quite interesting and could be another perfectly viable option to put into the game.

I wouldn’t mind this one so I’m going with

If it’s implemented I think it should be uncommon or somewhat rare, probably in a Diamond Lucky Block

I agree with this, it would have the same chance of appearing as the red leather boots of Blast protection 10

 

[Fjackp14_]

Could you talk about why you are not sure about this idea, or what change you would make to it?

K so my first thing is what kind of armour? I think diamond would be good but to go all that way just for that. I say any part of diamond armour, 2 gapples and maybe an ender pearl to make it just a tiny bit better

 

[Velocidad]

K so my first thing is what kind of armour? I think diamond would be good but to go all that way just for that. I say any part of diamond armour, 2 gapples and maybe an ender pearl to make it just a tiny bit better

Well, this is an interesting point, since I think it depends a lot on the mode. First of all, we have to keep in mind that the drop from the chest where armor always comes out if you vote normal or blessed can appear if I'm not mistaken from leather armor to iron, knowing this, from a point of view of the blessed and normal mode, I think the best thing would be to make parts of iron armor always appear and that they are rarely enchanted with protection 1 + 1 golden apple. But on the other hand, in op I think it's true that the appearance of diamond armor parts would make more sense and putting more golden apples as you mention makes a lot of sense, but it's true that I wouldn't add the ender pearl.

 

[Fjackp14_]

Well, this is an interesting point, since I think it depends a lot on the mode. First of all, we have to keep in mind that the drop from the chest where armor always comes out if you vote normal or blessed can appear if I'm not mistaken from leather armor to iron, knowing this, from a point of view of the blessed and normal mode, I think the best thing would be to make parts of iron armor always appear and that they are rarely enchanted with protection 1 + 1 golden apple. But on the other hand, in op I think it's true that the appearance of diamond armor parts would make more sense and putting more golden apples as you mention makes a lot of sense, but it's true that I wouldn't add the ender pearl.

Ok then. Very good points

 

[Roxrock]

Here are some of my thoughts:

1. As you’ve mentioned, hostile mob spawn eggs are currently Java exclusive. I’m not sure why this is the case and would like to see hostile mob spawn eggs in bedrock edition as well. I also strongly agree with having a wider variety of possible spawn eggs.
2. I agree with this drop and think it would be a good fit, although I personally think it would be fine without sharpness in regular game modes and sharpness 2 in overpowered mode. I understand that java’s combat system plays a role into balancing, I think you can deal more damage in a shorter amount of time in bedrock and each level of sharpness adds 1.25 damage instead of 0.75. Unfortunately, I don’t think these versions of the game are being balanced independently of each other even though I think they definitely should. (I also understand that shulker sword being at sharpness 2 in normal mode might make it outclass the other special swords, but this problem would be best solved by removing the sharpness of the shulker sword and lifesteal sword in regular modes. I’m begging to suspect that these swords were added outside of overpowered mode on accident since in bedrock they only drop from diamond lucky blocks except for in overpowered mode where they drop from regular lucky blocks as well. If I were to balance all of the special swords in the game at once besides the giga sword, I honestly think having them as stone swords would be the best so that other ways of dealing damage such as wands, mobs, potions, etc. were more useful. It could also make anvils useful, perhaps these swords with special effects could be combined with sharpness stone swords using an anvil.)
3. As a mobile player I’m not 100% sure what all this would disable, but it seems like it should be balanced as long as the effect is also applied to the user. I also think it might need a slightly bigger radius.
4. Overall, this is my favorite idea on this list. The only thing I’m a little unsure about is the drop distribution, which I would prefer to be more diverse and random. First, I would add the possibility of getting lots of sand, gold nuggets, dried kelp, and a spyglass which would emphasize the pirate theme of this item. Instead of only giving armor, I would favor a distribution that primarily gives raw materials including generous amounts of gold ingots, iron ingots, and a chance for some diamonds. It would still have some chance to give the player one or two pieces of mid-tier gear, perhaps with the chance of enchaments. I also think tnt and some random splash potions would fit in well enough with this loot. I agree with golden apples being a possibility but don’t think they should be a guarantee, and would also like to see cooked fish as a possibility as well.
5. I’m not crazy about this idea because it feels like a relatively bland idea but don’t think it would harm the game by being added. I might support this idea more if the boots actually did something special other than an enchantment, like the tnt boots and fire chestplate. Maybe giving the player slow falling, or allowing the player to hover in the air for 3 seconds by holding down the jump button.
6. This is an idea I’m very unsure about, it seems really punishing for what it does. I feel like using a regular golden apples can give you 10 health without anything bad besides the eating animation. I really only see this item being worth using if I’m in a desperate situation. I would rework this item in the following way: When the item is used, the player heals/gains an additional 6 hearts, but the players entire health becomes absorption hearts, meaning they can no longer heal without gaining more absorption hearts from golden apples. Instead of the item being a luck based last resort, the punishment is consistent and players will be forced to decide whether they want to take that punishment, or risk not using that item when they are low health in a fight.
7. Another idea I strongly agree with, I have nothing more to add.
8. This idea is alright and would help fix a drop that is currently really dry, it might work better as a replacement for this drop though because the rest of the drop is still extremely useless.
9. I’m unsure about this idea, wouldn’t most enchantments do basically nothing when enchanted on a stick which would make the drop relatively pointless most of the time. I’m not sure if this issue could be fixed without making some drastic changes to how this drop works.
10. This is a pretty cool idea. I mainly like your idea for golden frogs more than for regular frogs, it might be annoying if the golden frogs jumps off of the map though. I completely agree with the concept you are going for though and think it is well balanced enough.

 

[Velocidad]

I agree with this drop and think it would be a good fit, although I personally think it would be fine without sharpness in regular game modes and sharpness 2 in overpowered mode. I understand that java’s combat system plays a role into balancing, I think you can deal more damage in a shorter amount of time in bedrock and each level of sharpness adds 1.25 damage instead of 0.75. Unfortunately, I don’t think these versions of the game are being balanced independently of each other even though I think they definitely should. (I also understand that shulker sword being at sharpness 2 in normal mode might make it outclass the other special swords, but this problem would be best solved by removing the sharpness of the shulker sword and lifesteal sword in regular modes. I’m begging to suspect that these swords were added outside of overpowered mode on accident since in bedrock they only drop from diamond lucky blocks except for in overpowered mode where they drop from regular lucky blocks as well. If I were to balance all of the special swords in the game at once besides the giga sword, I honestly think having them as stone swords would be the best so that other ways of dealing damage such as wands, mobs, potions, etc. were more useful. It could also make anvils useful, perhaps these swords with special effects could be combined with sharpness stone swords using an anvil.)

I think that the damage that these special swords do is pretty good in Java, so I don't think it needs any balance, but it's true that in Bedrock the changes you mention may be necessary because PVP is different. On the other hand, the shulker sword, at least in Java, is fine as it is currently because the power of the sword is not that good, and people would not use it otherwise since it is not very difficult to obtain better swords like lifesteal sword or enchant a diamond sword with sharpness 1. I'm also not entirely convinced by the stone swords. In Java, the kit that gives you 7 diamonds is the most popular and the best of all, meaning that the special swords would be quite unimportant.

As a mobile player I’m not 100% sure what all this would disable, but it seems like it should be balanced as long as the effect is also applied to the user. I also think it might need a slightly bigger radius.

Everyone within the wand's effect would be affected by the same effect, even the user who used the wand.Regarding the radius, it would be a matter of seeing it in-game and seeing if any changes are necessary, since it is not easy to see if any balance is needed without testing it, but keep in mind that if the wand effect is still active and you leave the radius, it will continue with that effect for 3 more seconds. This was thought of in case someone tries to escape from the effect by jumping into the void to use the elevator, the shield wand, ender pearls, etc.

Overall, this is my favorite idea on this list. The only thing I’m a little unsure about is the drop distribution, which I would prefer to be more diverse and random. First, I would add the possibility of getting lots of sand, gold nuggets, dried kelp, and a spyglass which would emphasize the pirate theme of this item. Instead of only giving armor, I would favor a distribution that primarily gives raw materials including generous amounts of gold ingots, iron ingots, and a chance for some diamonds. It would still have some chance to give the player one or two pieces of mid-tier gear, perhaps with the chance of enchaments. I also think tnt and some random splash potions would fit in well enough with this loot. I agree with golden apples being a possibility but don’t think they should be a guarantee, and would also like to see cooked fish as a possibility as well.

Although I find the idea you propose interesting, you have to keep in mind that the loot that appears in these chests has to be good enough and guarantee you something so that you bother to go for it instead of going to break more lucky blocks that can give you other more useful things and without the risk of being attacked while you go for the chest on the treasure map.And the potions thing might be good but I'm not really sure.

I’m not crazy about this idea because it feels like a relatively bland idea but don’t think it would harm the game by being added. I might support this idea more if the boots actually did something special other than an enchantment, like the tnt boots and fire chestplate. Maybe giving the player slow falling, or allowing the player to hover in the air for 3 seconds by holding down the jump button.

It is true that this idea is not special but it was not our intention either, although the idea of hover for 3 seconds seems very good to me and I think it would be very interesting to see, I could think of other boots that are not these (Cloud boots) that were like a jetpack that you could propel yourself upwards or glide/hover like you say for a few seconds.

This is an idea I’m very unsure about, it seems really punishing for what it does. I feel like using a regular golden apples can give you 10 health without anything bad besides the eating animation. I really only see this item being worth using if I’m in a desperate situation. I would rework this item in the following way: When the item is used, the player heals/gains an additional 6 hearts, but the players entire health becomes absorption hearts, meaning they can no longer heal without gaining more absorption hearts from golden apples. Instead of the item being a luck based last resort, the punishment is consistent and players will be forced to decide whether they want to take that punishment, or risk not using that item when they are low health in a fight.

This item was thought as a last resort so I don't think it requires a change from the point of view we had to create this item, but your idea seems very cool, it could be another type of heart, names like Absolute absorption or something simpler like absorption heart could fit perfectly for this type of heart. I think it would be very interesting to see different types of hearts like with special swords or wands.

This idea is alright and would help fix a drop that is currently really dry, it might work better as a replacement for this drop though because the rest of the drop is still extremely useless.

It could perfectly be a possibility, I was also thinking about adding a drop that, just like when the Chorus plant appears, would be a drop from of a bamboo that also grows and if you break it there is a possibility that it will drop the blowguns, since it seems like a waste to me to develop an item like this just for the drop of bamboo + sticks + sugarcane

I’m unsure about this idea, wouldn’t most enchantments do basically nothing when enchanted on a stick which would make the drop relatively pointless most of the time. I’m not sure if this issue could be fixed without making some drastic changes to how this drop works.

We didn't intend for this item to be very useful in most cases, our idea was for it to be very dependent on luck and obviously in most cases it would be useless, but in a few it would be quite broken. Shamomshka came up with the idea to be only tool enchantment but we thought that it would be more interesting and fun being any kind of enchantment.

Spoiler: :)

Btw, as always, thank you very much for taking your time to make these feedback, which are very well explained and always with very interesting points of view that never disappoint.

 

[Roxrock]

I think that the damage that these special swords do is pretty good in Java, so I don't think it needs any balance, but it's true that in Bedrock the changes you mention may be necessary because PVP is different. On the other hand, the shulker sword, at least in Java, is fine as it is currently because the power of the sword is not that good, and people would not use it otherwise since it is not very difficult to obtain better swords like lifesteal sword or enchant a diamond sword with sharpness 1. I'm also not entirely convinced by the stone swords. In Java, the kit that gives you 7 diamonds is the most popular and the best of all, meaning that the special swords would be quite unimportant.

I’m glad you mentioned that kit since it doesn’t exist in bedrock and I agree that what kits give you should be overall weaker than the loot you obtain from lucky blocks. Kits in bedrock are much weaker, one gives you a wooden sword, one gives cooked beef, one gives some stone block, and one gives a golden apple with some splash health potions. (I actually really wish these kits were different and have made feedback suggesting different kits in the past.) If they were reduced to stone swords the kit you mentioned would probably have to be changed too, but I think it would just be better if bedrock and Java had separate balancing. The point I was trying to make here is that making the ender sword a regular iron sword would make it balanced with the game in it’s current state, but if I were to consider how much damage it should deal without considering these other weapons, I would make it relatively weak because I believe that weapons in lucky islands are generally too strong and that you tend to die in relatively few hits. I suppose this should probably be its own feedback topic though. Having it be an iron sword with sharpness 1 would still make it relatively balanced with the current weapons even in bedrock.

Although I find the idea you propose interesting, you have to keep in mind that the loot that appears in these chests has to be good enough and guarantee you something so that you bother to go for it instead of going to break more lucky blocks that can give you other more useful things and without the risk of being attacked while you go for the chest on the treasure map.And the potions thing might be good but I'm not really sure.

I agree that the quality of the loot needs to be high enough in order to incentivize players to actually obtain it. However, I’m unsure that your original idea would have loot that is consistently beneficial. The problem with receiving armor in chests is that its usefulness strongly depends on what armor the player already has for the armor slot the piece of armor belongs to. An iron chestplate is useless to a solo player who already has one, buts it’s really strong if you don’t have any chestplates besides it. In contrast, having raw iron and diamonds would allow player to craft the specific armor they are missing or have weak armor in, which would make it useful consistently, especially diamonds since diamond armor in lucky islands is relatively rare. The armor with enchantments could also be useful considering how rare enchanted armor is for lucky islands. The usefulness of the potions would admittedly vary and I would be hesitant to include strength considering how much of an advantage it is, but I included the idea since I wanted to include some items that might make this loot less generic.
I understand that having rng based loot could result in there being cases where you get unlucky and the loot isn’t very useful. I can think of two solutions to this. You could have it so that there is a handful of preset chest layouts which are approximately the same in quality but contain different items, then have the game choose one of those and have the chest contain that exact set of items. The other solution would be making certain items guaranteed but vary the quantity of that item that is given. For example, the chest could always give the player 8 to 20 iron, and even if the player only receives 8 iron they still have the ability to craft any piece of iron armor.

We didn't intend for this item to be very useful in most cases, our idea was for it to be very dependent on luck and obviously in most cases it would be useless, but in a few it would be quite broken. Shamomshka came up with the idea to be only tool enchantment but we thought that it would be more interesting and fun being any kind of enchantment.

The issue I have with this items relative uselessness is that in the cases where the enchantment doesn’t do anything, the entire drop has no impact on the way that the game goes. There are obviously several cases of this already in the game, blaze rods, grass, as well as the bamboo and glitched lucky blocks as you’ve mentioned. While I think having a few drops from normal lucky blocks that are neither helpful nor hurtful is good, I would prefer that such drops do something significant for the game. An example is most structures which, although they usually don’t benefit or hurt players, they modify the terrain which can help make each game more unique. A mob like a shulker can at least interrupt fights between players or give players an opportunity to use levitation to their advantage. Having a stick with quick charge and the only thing it’s good for is crafting, but sticks are almost always obtainable from wood on the map and are given from the bamboo drop and dissolving material. If this drop were to be added, the chance of every other interesting and impactful drop happening becomes slightly less likely which is why the number of drops that don’t do much of anything should be limited. In my opinion several of the other drop ideas you have suggested would be a lot better and some of them even manage to make improvements to existing drops that are currently very dull and haven’t potential be something better. I just want to avoid having another case of the infinitato.

And of course, I’m still very thankful for you making this feedback. I can tell that you really care about lucky islands in a similar way as myself. I’m really hoping that the game can continue to grow and be improved so that more people can find the same enjoyment in the game that we have. I’m also grateful for the amount of polish and detail you put into making this feedback and I think it’s helped a lot with bringing these threads enough attention and making them more likely to be considered. I look forward to whatever feedback or ideas you may bring in the future.